优化DBLE独立子查询教程
01问题
前期开发反馈在使用独立子查询时，不论子查询中结果集有几个，语句都会卡死迟迟得不到返回结果。但是如果去掉子查询，直接赋值查询很快得到返回结果。听到这个情况第一反应很可能DBLE在独立子查询上没有做相关优化，真的是这样么？下面我们将问题复现以及优化方式进行展示。
02 演示及优化
环境检查
DBLE版本：2.19.11.5
MySQL版本：5.7.28
涉及分片表：src_biz_filelist
分片键：batch_no
涉及垂直表：src_image_txn_jnl
分片拆分规则：stringhash
节点数量：4
2.1 原始语句及执行计划
独立子查询语句如下：
select caption,batch_no,image_no from src_biz_filelist where batch_no in (SELECT imageid FROM src_image_txn_jnl WHERE front_seq_num = '001780568097' and txn_dt = '2029-08-20')
执行计划如下：
mysql> explain select caption,batch_no,image_no from src_biz_filelist where batch_no in (SELECT imageid FROM src_image_txn_jnl WHERE front_seq_num = '001780568097' and txn_dt = '2029-08-20');
+-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| DATA_NODE | TYPE | SQL/REF |
+-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| dn1_0 | BASE SQL | select `src_biz_filelist`.`ysyid`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`create_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`update_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`img_seql`,`src_biz_filelist`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` ORDER BY `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` ASC |
| dn2_0 | BASE SQL | select `src_biz_filelist`.`ysyid`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`create_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`update_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`img_seql`,`src_biz_filelist`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` ORDER BY `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` ASC |
| dn3_0 | BASE SQL | select `src_biz_filelist`.`ysyid`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`create_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`update_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`img_seql`,`src_biz_filelist`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` ORDER BY `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` ASC |
| dn4_0 | BASE SQL | select `src_biz_filelist`.`ysyid`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`create_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`update_time`,`src_biz_filelist`.`img_seql`,`src_biz_filelist`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` ORDER BY `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` ASC |
| merge_and_order_1 | MERGE_AND_ORDER | dn1_0; dn2_0; dn3_0; dn4_0 |
| shuffle_field_1 | SHUFFLE_FIELD | merge_and_order_1 |
| dn1_1 | BASE SQL | select `autoalias_src_image_txn_jnl`.`autoalias_scalar` from (select distinct `src_image_txn_jnl`.`imageid` as `autoalias_scalar` from `src_image_txn_jnl` where (`src_image_txn_jnl`.`front_seq_num` = '001780568097') AND (`src_image_txn_jnl`.`txn_dt` = '2029-08-20') order by autoalias_scalar ASC) autoalias_src_image_txn_jnl order by `autoalias_src_image_txn_jnl`.`autoalias_scalar` ASC |
| merge_1 | MERGE | dn1_1 |
| join_1 | JOIN | shuffle_field_1; merge_1 |
| shuffle_field_2 | SHUFFLE_FIELD | join_1 |
+-------------------+-----------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
10 rows in set (0.00 sec)
**执行计划可见，DBLE对语句进行了拆分。首先分别在4个数据节点全表扫描分片表src_biz_filelist，将各自返回的结果集在DBLE层合并排序。然后将子查询结果去重排序后返回。最后在DBLE层进行匹配操作。当分片表数据量较大时，全部提取数据动作，即使不与子查询中结果集匹配，效率也不会很好。
**
按照开发描述改写子查询语句赋予具体值，进行查看：
mysql> explain select caption,batch_no,image_no from src_biz_filelist where batch_no in ('0250002403989000IMMEDA200630095447WV','1650002432532000IMMEDA200630095233WS');
+-----------+----------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| DATA_NODE | TYPE | SQL/REF |
+-----------+----------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| dn4 | BASE SQL | select caption,batch_no,image_no from src_biz_filelist where batch_no in ('0250002403989000IMMEDA200630095447WV','1650002432532000IMMEDA200630095233WS') |
+-----------+----------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
1 rows in set (0.00 sec)
因为分片表src_biz_filelist的分片键为batch_no，语句直接下压到了数据所在的dn4节点。验证了开发描述的在使用独立子查询时，不论子查询中结果集有几个，语句都会卡死迟迟得不到返回结果。如果去掉子查询赋予具体值，很快得到返回结果。程序进行语句拆分传入具体值查询，也是我们的优化方法之一。那是不是DBLE在独立子查询上真的没有做相关优化呢？我们继续操作。
**2.2 **独立标量子查询语句及执行计划
如果明确子查询结果单个值情况下，可以改写使用独立标量子查询，执行计划如下：
mysql> explain select caption,batch_no,image_no from src_biz_filelist where batch_no = (SELECT imageid FROM src_image_txn_jnl WHERE front_seq_num = '001780568097' and txn_dt = '2029-08-20');
+--------------------+-----------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| DATA_NODE | TYPE | SQL/REF |
+--------------------+-----------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| dn1_0 | BASE SQL | select `src_image_txn_jnl`.`imageid` as `autoalias_scalar` from `src_image_txn_jnl` where (`src_image_txn_jnl`.`front_seq_num` = '001780568097') AND (`src_image_txn_jnl`.`txn_dt` = '2029-08-20') limit 0,2 |
| merge_1 | MERGE | dn1_0 |
| scalar_sub_query_1 | SCALAR_SUB_QUERY | merge_1 |
| dn1_1 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | scalar_sub_query_1; select `src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no` from `src_biz_filelist` where `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` = '{NEED_TO_REPLACE}' |
| dn2_0 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | scalar_sub_query_1; select `src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no` from `src_biz_filelist` where `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` = '{NEED_TO_REPLACE}' |
| dn3_0 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | scalar_sub_query_1; select `src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no` from `src_biz_filelist` where `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` = '{NEED_TO_REPLACE}' |
| dn4_0 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | scalar_sub_query_1; select `src_biz_filelist`.`caption`,`src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no`,`src_biz_filelist`.`image_no` from `src_biz_filelist` where `src_biz_filelist`.`batch_no` = '{NEED_TO_REPLACE}' |
| merge_2 | MERGE | dn1_1; dn2_0; dn3_0; dn4_0 |
| shuffle_field_1 | SHUFFLE_FIELD | merge_2 |
+--------------------+-----------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
9 rows in set (0.00 sec)
执行计划可见：dn1_0部分先将子查询结果返回，出现了SCALAR_SUB_QUERY标量子查询的标识，被引用到外部查询中，语句直接下压到了全部数据节点。这种情况下依据分片键进行等值查询，效率是OK的。
****03 解决
通过查看原始语句在DBLE的执行计划，下压到MySQL时，由于DBLE对语句进行了重写，并没有使用到MySQL优化器改写语句为semi join方式。在MySQL中需要使用子查询完成的任务，很多时候可以使用连接方式来实现，那么我们在上层就重写为join语句实验一下。
查看DBLE文档server.xml 系统参数配置部分有一个useJoinStrategy参数，该参数作用是开启之后会尝试判断join两边的where来重新调整查询SQL下发的顺序，默认关闭。添加true至server.xml的标签中，并重启DBLE。
查看改写之后语句执行计划：
mysql> explain select t1.caption,t1.batch_no,t1.image_no from src_biz_filelist t1 inner join src_image_txn_jnl t2 on t1.batch_no=t2.imageid WHERE t2.front_seq_num = '001780568097' and t2.txn_dt = '2029-08-20';
+-------------------+-----------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| DATA_NODE | TYPE | SQL/REF |
+-------------------+-----------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| dn1_0 | BASE SQL | select `t2`.`id`,`t2`.`evt_id`,`t2`.`front_seq_num`,`t2`.`org_id`,`t2`.`teller_id`,`t2`.`txn_dt`,`t2`.`txn_tm`,`t2`.`txn_type_cd`,`t2`.`txn_cd`,`t2`.`sub_seq_num`,`t2`.`bcs_seq_num`,`t2`.`user_ccy_cd`,`t2`.`acct_num`,`t2`.`acct_ccy_cd`,`t2`.`acct_amt`,`t2`.`txn_ccy_cd`,`t2`.`txn_amt`,`t2`.`exch_rate`,`t2`.`resp_num`,`t2`.`proc_info`,`t2`.`auth_teller_id`,`t2`.`terminal_num`,`t2`.`cntrpty_acct_num`,`t2`.`cntrpty_acct_name`,`t2`.`vchr_type_encode`,`t2`.`vchr_num`,`t2`.`vchr_dt`,`t2`.`chk_teller_id`,`t2`.`vchr_main_file_desc`,`t2`.`vchr_accessory_desc`,`t2`.`biz_status_cd`,`t2`.`fin_txn_ind`,`t2`.`txn_complt_dt`,`t2`.`ident_chk_chker_id`,`t2`.`ident_chk_result_cd`,`t2`.`veri_seal_chker_id`,`t2`.`veri_seal_result_cd`,`t2`.`tel_che_chker_id`,`t2`.`tel_che_result_cd`,`t2`.`tel_che_comment`,`t2`.`pay_acct_doubt_type_cd`,`t2`.`rcv_acct_doubt_type_cd`,`t2`.`job_center`,`t2`.`imageid`,`t2`.`pay_name`,`t2`.`txn_desc`,`t2`.`origin_txn_seq_num`,`t2`.`txn_start_tm`,`t2`.`txn_memo`,`t2`.`bcs_or_back_txn_num`,`t2`.`bea_intrfc_num`,`t2`.`txn_auth_teller`,`t2`.`send_back_or_back_err_info`,`t2`.`data_date` from `src_image_txn_jnl` `t2` where (`t2`.`front_seq_num` = '001780568097') AND (`t2`.`txn_dt` = '2029-08-20') order by `t2`.`imageid` ASC |
| merge_1 | MERGE | dn1_0 |
| nest_loop_1 | NEST_LOOP | merge_1 |
| dn1_1 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | nest_loop_1's RESULTS; select `t1`.`ysyid`,`t1`.`batch_no`,`t1`.`image_no`,`t1`.`caption`,`t1`.`create_time`,`t1`.`update_time`,`t1`.`img_seql`,`t1`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` `t1` where t1.batch_no IN ('{NEED_TO_REPLACE}') ORDER BY `t1`.`batch_no` ASC |
| dn2_0 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | nest_loop_1's RESULTS; select `t1`.`ysyid`,`t1`.`batch_no`,`t1`.`image_no`,`t1`.`caption`,`t1`.`create_time`,`t1`.`update_time`,`t1`.`img_seql`,`t1`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` `t1` where t1.batch_no IN ('{NEED_TO_REPLACE}') ORDER BY `t1`.`batch_no` ASC |
| dn3_0 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | nest_loop_1's RESULTS; select `t1`.`ysyid`,`t1`.`batch_no`,`t1`.`image_no`,`t1`.`caption`,`t1`.`create_time`,`t1`.`update_time`,`t1`.`img_seql`,`t1`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` `t1` where t1.batch_no IN ('{NEED_TO_REPLACE}') ORDER BY `t1`.`batch_no` ASC |
| dn4_0 | BASE SQL(May No Need) | nest_loop_1's RESULTS; select `t1`.`ysyid`,`t1`.`batch_no`,`t1`.`image_no`,`t1`.`caption`,`t1`.`create_time`,`t1`.`update_time`,`t1`.`img_seql`,`t1`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` `t1` where t1.batch_no IN ('{NEED_TO_REPLACE}') ORDER BY `t1`.`batch_no` ASC |
| merge_and_order_1 | MERGE_AND_ORDER | dn1_1; dn2_0; dn3_0; dn4_0 |
| shuffle_field_1 | SHUFFLE_FIELD | merge_and_order_1 |
| join_1 | JOIN | nest_loop_1; shuffle_field_1 |
| shuffle_field_2 | SHUFFLE_FIELD | join_1 |
+-------------------+-----------------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
11 rows in set (0.00 sec)
执行计划可见：dn1_0部分先将子查询结果返回，出现了NEST_LOOP嵌套循环标识，嵌套循环的结果集被引用到外部查询中，语句直接下压到了全部数据节点。
开启MySQL general_log 日志查看语句实际在MySQL层运行情况如下：
2021-05-12T08:58:09.324017+08:00 1080 Query select `t2`.`id`,`t2`.`evt_id`,`t2`.`front_seq_num`,`t2`.`org_id`,`t2`.`teller_id`,`t2`.`txn_dt`,`t2`.`txn_tm`,`t2`.`txn_type_cd`,`t2`.`txn_cd`,`t2`.`sub_seq_num`,`t2`.`bcs_seq_num`,`t2`.`user_ccy_cd`,`t2`.`acct_num`,`t2`.`acct_ccy_cd`,`t2`.`acct_amt`,`t2`.`txn_ccy_cd`,`t2`.`txn_amt`,`t2`.`exch_rate`,`t2`.`resp_num`,`t2`.`proc_info`,`t2`.`auth_teller_id`,`t2`.`terminal_num`,`t2`.`cntrpty_acct_num`,`t2`.`cntrpty_acct_name`,`t2`.`vchr_type_encode`,`t2`.`vchr_num`,`t2`.`vchr_dt`,`t2`.`chk_teller_id`,`t2`.`vchr_main_file_desc`,`t2`.`vchr_accessory_desc`,`t2`.`biz_status_cd`,`t2`.`fin_txn_ind`,`t2`.`txn_complt_dt`,`t2`.`ident_chk_chker_id`,`t2`.`ident_chk_result_cd`,`t2`.`veri_seal_chker_id`,`t2`.`veri_seal_result_cd`,`t2`.`tel_che_chker_id`,`t2`.`tel_che_result_cd`,`t2`.`tel_che_comment`,`t2`.`pay_acct_doubt_type_cd`,`t2`.`rcv_acct_doubt_type_cd`,`t2`.`job_center`,`t2`.`imageid`,`t2`.`pay_name`,`t2`.`txn_desc`,`t2`.`origin_txn_seq_num`,`t2`.`txn_start_tm`,`t2`.`txn_memo`,`t2`.`bcs_or_back_txn_num`,`t2`.`bea_intrfc_num`,`t2`.`txn_auth_teller`,`t2`.`send_back_or_back_err_info`,`t2`.`data_date` from `src_image_txn_jnl` `t2` where (`t2`.`front_seq_num` = '001780568097') AND (`t2`.`txn_dt` = '2029-08-20') order by `t2`.`imageid` ASC
2021-05-12T08:58:09.326400+08:00 1091 Query select `t1`.`ysyid`,`t1`.`batch_no`,`t1`.`image_no`,`t1`.`caption`,`t1`.`create_time`,`t1`.`update_time`,`t1`.`img_seql`,`t1`.`data_date` from `src_biz_filelist` `t1` where t1.batch_no IN ('0250002403989000IMMEDA200630095447WV', '0250002401013000IMMEDA200914092919JX') ORDER BY `t1`.`batch_no` ASC
语句执行顺序变化，独立子查询被赋予了具体值，并按分片键进行数据路由的特性，下发到指定分片节点进行查询。
需要注意的是关于nestLoop还有两个参数nestLoopConnSize /nestLoopRowsSize 若临时表行数大于这两个值乘积，DBLE则会报告一个后端连接错误。
综上优化方式有以下几种：
1、程序进行语句拆分传入具体值进行查询。
2、如果明确子查询结果单个值情况下，可以改写使用独立标量子查询。
3、添加 true 参数，并改写为连接查询。
声明：本文内容及配图由入驻作者撰写或者入驻合作网站授权转载。文章观点仅代表作者本人，不代表电子发烧友网立场。文章及其配图仅供工程师学习之用，如有内容侵权或者其他违规问题，请联系本站处理。
举报投诉
-
开发
+关注
关注
0文章
366浏览量
40805 -
数据库
+关注
关注
7文章
3761浏览量
64268 -
MySQL
+关注
关注
1文章
801浏览量
26437
发布评论请先 登录
相关推荐
基于关系代数树的查询优化方法实例分析
提出了基于关系代数树结构的SQL查询优化策略。利用改进查询计划的代数定律，分析基于关系代数树的关系代数式查询优化方法、研究关系代数表达式与S
发表于 05-07 10:11
•21次下载
基于共享执行策略的间隔查询优化
间隔查询作为重要的查询类型，广泛应用在社交网络、信息检索和数据库领域．为了支持高效的间隔查询，涌现出多种优化技术．尽管已有方法能够快速响应单个间隔查
发表于 01-05 17:09
•0次下载
基于Greenplum数据库的查询优化
针对分布式数据库查询效率随着数据规模的增大而降低的问题，以Greenplum分布式数据库为研究对象，从优化查询路径的角度提出一个基于代价的最优查询计划生成方法。首先，该方法设计一种有效
发表于 03-29 17:46
•0次下载
数据库系统概论之如何进行关系查询处理和查询优化
本文档的主要内容详细介绍的是数据库系统概论之如何进行关系查询处理和查询优化主要内容包括了：1、关系数据库系统的查询处理 2、关系数据库系统的查询
发表于 11-15 15:12
•11次下载
工商网监
评论